West Indians: We Are People Too, Mon

West Indians: We Are People Too, Mon

“Prejudice. . . yes, but not only in New York City. There is prejudice everywhere there’s West Indians,” says Glen Joseph, a member of the Trinidad and Tobago Alliance, on the question of biased feelings toward West Indians in New York City.
Responding to the same question, Marie St. Cyr, head of the Haitian Centers Council (a group which assists Haitian immigrants), said, “People are prejudiced against anything they don’t understand. There is prejudice against Haitians because they are Black, just like there is against Jamaicans, Trinidadians, and other people who are different.”
Many Stereotypes
For West Indian teenagers, however, it is much more difficult to adjust. Haitian youths, especially, have a harder time, because of the stereotyped view of them.
“There are a number of stereotypes for Haitians. People see them as carrying diseases and a lot of other things,” said Marie St. Cyr.
Because of stereotyping, people seem to just ignore us, and we must abandon our culture and our whole way of living to be considered acceptable. We are often categorized by the view that all West Indians are alike, when we are not.
Haitians, for example, have a whole different way of speaking. Their language is Creole, a French dialect.
In Jamaica we speak a kind of English, known as Patois. Trinidadians also speak broken English, but it is different from the way Jamaicans speak it. The accent is what makes it different. Sometimes a Jamaican finds it hard to understand what a Trinidadian is saying, or the other way around.
“Yes, I am West Indian, but I am not Jamaican,” said an 18-year-old Trinidadian at Erasmus Hall HS. “I can’t believe how many times people have assumed that I am Jamaican just because I tell them that I am from the West Indies. There are a lot of other countries in the West Indies. Why don’t people learn them?”
It is an unfortunate fact that every immigrant group experiences racial prejudice because they are different and often misunderstood.
Haitians and AIDs
Ignorance breeds many stereotypes. “All Haitians stink and are nasty. When I say all, I mean ALL. I have not seen a Haitian person who was well-dressed and wasn’t acting loud and rowdy. They are the ones who brought AIDS to our country. It didn’t become an epidemic until they came,” remarked a 16-year-old Black American at Clara Barton HS (name withheld).
An 18-year-old Haitian-American responded in fury:
“I don’t know why people say that we brought AIDS, because as far as I know, it was here before many people knew about it! I never even heard of AIDS before I came to America. Also, I don’t act rowdy and I do dress nicely, so that rumor about all Haitians couldn’t possibly be true.”
There are many West Indian countries in the Caribbean and each one has its own individual way of life. Each culture should be looked upon as being unique, and so should each West Indian.
“Whenever there is a group of people who is not understood, people just assume things about them, or the first rumor they hear is what they use to label them,” said 16-year-old Angela Matthews of John Dewey HS.
Success Brings Jealousy
Some Jamaicans, Haitians, Dominicans, or Trinidadians encounter jealousy when they come to this country and succeed here. But each person is responsible for herself-she has to take the praise if she succeeds and the blame if she fails.
“If Americans are the victims when West Indian immigrants succeed here, then they are the victims anyway for not working harder at developing their skills to succeed,” said Glen Joseph.
West Indians are proud of their experiences and cultures, which give them a unique outlook on American life.
“What I’ve noticed is that American teenagers don’t have respect for their elders or teachers. I’ve noticed they have a more carefree attitude and they don’t really care that much about rules,” said 21-year-old Daniel Burke from Jamaica.
“I feel privileged to have been born in Jamaica,” he said, “because, first of all, the educational system is strict and that makes you learn. The system here has gotten a lot worse since I’ve been here. Secondly, you just can’t beat the cooking in Jamaica.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.