Are High Schools Preparing Students for College Admission?

Are you well-informed about what you need to do to apply to colleges? Many of you are, but most of you probably are not.
Recently, teens from various high schools around the city gave their views on college admissions. They talked about how they find out about colleges and how their high schools help them make the decisions.
“Most of the people in my class are not thinking about college,” said Walter Crawford, 17, a senior at George Westinghouse. “They are not ready to go. I wish I had started my research for colleges earlier.”
“At the end of my junior year, I looked up information about LIU (Brooklyn Campus), NYU, Brooklyn College, and Hofstra,” said April Symmes, 16, a senior at Lafayette HS. “We have a college office that is open at any time for seniors and juniors.”
‘I Feel Cheated’
Many of the students interviewed were not satisfied with their college counselors, and felt cheated of important information or felt peers were lacking information.
“I know people who don’t know where to turn and don’t know what they are going to do in the future,” says Marc Bonhomme, 16, of Art & Design HS. A junior, he wisely is preparing for his senior year.
“I feel cheated due to lack of information about SAT forms and college admissions. No one told me I’d graduate this year,” said a senior at Graphic Communication Arts HS. “I didn’t know I had enough credits until they told me. Now I have to get a job and find out about more colleges.
“I need to talk to my counselor more often. He wasn’t available most of the time. There should be more advisors for seniors-two, three, or more,” he continued.
A senior from Thomas Jefferson HS said, “They’ll help us, but when they get the information, they don’t give it to us in advance.”
“They always let you know late about your credits,” says a 17-year-old from Springfield Gardens HS.
Frederick Foster, 18, a senior at Graphic Communication Arts HS, said: “Definitely, I’d like to know more about financing for college. And I’d like to know more about writing essays for college applications.
“Some of my friends are not thinking about going to college, because they don’t want another four years of schooling.
“If they don’t help themselves, no one will,” he concluded.
Marianne Mason, 16, a Thomas Jefferson HS senior, mentioned how her college advisor gives assistance.
“She does help me. She’ll point out college references and things like that. She points out the most important things.
“If we don’t care about ourselves, we will be totally uninformed. The advisors will not always come to us,” Marianne noted.
Linda Seabron, 17, a senior at Harry Van Arsdale HS (formerly Eli Whitney HS), said her college advisor “Is mostly available in school. If he has a class, he’ll ask us what time we can come to him.
“He took time if we didn’t understand. He took the time to make sure we had it right, which most counselors don’t take the time to do.”
But she added, “If students want to be informed, they can’t depend on one person. It is very simple to write a letter. You’re the one who is going to college. I don’t think one should wait until the last minute.”
Not Enough Advisors
Jay Johnson, 17, a senior at Springfield Gardens HS, expressed dissatisfaction with both his college advisor’s assistance and his peers.
“When they do help me out, they spend only about five minutes to talk, with the little time they have. We have to make a schedule, wait for the next week to come. The counselors are always on the go. There should be at least four college advisors. In my school we only have two.”
Jay also said, “The students are not paying attention! They should take the first step.”
Yes, it is the students’ job to see their advisors. But what about the students who do go to their college counselors, and don’t get enough attention because there are too few counselors?
“There is always room for more college advisors. . . but it is up to students to make appointments. A lot of students are shy-students should be more aggressive. The Big Apple College Fair is an example of how students can learn about college on their own,” said Selma Gross, administrator of college advisors for the Board of Education.
Richard Fuchs, college advisor at Graphic Communication Arts HS, has some advice for students.
“I counsel between 50 and 70 students each week. Our school has a Metro-Guide Service. This computer helps the student plan for his college career. It identifies colleges by majors and gives the student a broad view of what each college offers.
“In addition to this, we have a library of catalogs, which students may look at seven periods a day.
“According to my schedule, I’m here in my office four periods a day. I tell the students about all the college fairs. CUNY, SUNY, RIT, Pace, Franklin, and City University came to our school for recruitment,” he went on.
It’s The Student’s Job
Mr. Fuchs says, “My job is to show students how to apply to the colleges. The student’s job is to apply.”
When asked if there should be more college advisors in the high schools, he said, “I think there should be many more, yes.”
However, Fuchs makes the point that students must take a certain responsibility.
“Some students-not all-think the counselors should write to the colleges. Students want to go to college, but don’t want to do the paperwork to get there.”
Students and college advisors should work more closely, helping each other and informing each other. Be aggressive; communicate with your advisors. This option may be the best until the Board of Education finds a way to add more college advisors.
But high school advisors aren’t the only answer. Did you know there are private organizations where you can speak to counselors about colleges and admissions?
Free Counseling Is Available
Mario Morales, senior counselor at the East Harlem College & Career Counseling Program in Manhattan, makes appointments with many students. He sees more than 900 each year, and the counseling is free.
“We are very concerned about our students,” says Morales. “I follow up on our students.
“We do a thorough financial aid research for schools that the students are interested in. Also, we have fee waivers for SATs. We help with the whole application process, and essay writing.”
EHCCCP was founded in 1970 by Sue Cohen, a former English teacher at Park East HS. About 80% of the students who go to EHCCCP go to college, while 20% go to work.
“We follow our students up even when they are in the job market. They work for one semester, then come back,” says Morales.
Morales is concerned because he believes that 90% of his students don’t get the right information from their high schools. He knows that the college tests are important, but says, “There is more than one way to get into college, besides taking the SATs.”
Minorities Left Out
“I think that the Board of Ed is doing a terrible job. One counselor is not enough for 1,000 students,” says one of East Harlem’s counselors.
“They work with the top 5%-the other 95% don’t get enough attention. Basically, the minorities are left out.”
At East Harlem College & Career Counseling Program, there is a world open to those who will explore it. There are other programs like this one that can help you in applying to college (see sidebar). When it comes to college, you don’t have to be left in the dark.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.