Center for Constitutional Rights
What would happen if your parents found out that you were having sex and used birth control? For some teens it would be okay. For some it could mean getting kicked out of the house or even beat up.
In 1982, President Reagan’s administration suggested a national regulation, called the “Squeal Rule,” that would have forced family planning clinics to tell parents when their teenage daughters got birth control prescriptions. It also would have forced teens to bring proof of how much money their parents made to clinics so that the price of appointments and birth control could be decided.
For most teens, getting this information would have meant telling their parents that they were having sex and using birth control.
Privacy, Pregnancy& Discrimination
Luckily, the Squeal Rule did not become a law. If it had been enforced it would have had a lot of bad effects. Here are some of them:
o Invading the privacy of teens who should have the right to decide for themselves whether or not it’s a good idea to talk about sex with their parents? In some families, teens and parents can talk about sex in a positive way. But in some families telling your parents that you are sexually active can be a disaster, even leading to physical violence.
o Causing an increase in unwanted teenage pregnancies? The Squeal Rule would have scared many sexually active teens away from going to clinics to get birth control. This would have meant more pregnancies that were not wanted, more unwanted babies, and more abortions.
o Lowering the health of teenagers? Each year doctors in family planning clinics find cases of VD, cancer, and other health problems when they give checkups to teens coming in for birth control. This health care would no longer have reached teens if they were afraid to go to clinics because of the Squeal Rule.
o Discriminating against women? Since the Squeal Rule was only meant to squeal on people getting prescription birth control-such as the pill-it really would have affected only females. The Squeal Rule was basically saying that it’s okay for guys to have sex without their parents, knowing, but it’s not okay for girls.
Thousands of people wrote letters to the Reagan administration opposing the Squeal Rule. But, in January, 1983, the government decided to go ahead with it anyway. On January 26-the day that the Squeal Rule was supposed to go into effect-the Center for Constitutional Rights, the American Civil Liberties Union, the Medical and Health Research Association of New York City, and the State of New York, went to court saying that the Squeal Rule was illegal and harmful to teens. The judge in charge of the case stopped the Squeal Rule on the same day.
The Reagan administration tried to enforce the Squeal Rule in more court proceedings, but they kept losing. All the courts agreed that the laws passed by Congress (giving money to the clinics) say that teens have the choice of keeping their birth control business private. In November, 1983 the administration finally gave up.
The Squeal Rule may have caused a lot of talk, but it was never enforced for even one day. Because the Squeal Rule was in the news so much, a lot of teens thought they could not get birth control without their parents finding out. A lot of people still think so. But it isn’t true. Inside this paper you’ll find more about the issues that surfaced when the Squeal Rule hit the news. And in the box on this page you’ll find questions about the Squeal Rule.
SIDEBAR: Questions & Answers About Your Right to Privacy
Q. If I go to a clinic for birth control, is there a law which forces the clinic to tell my parents?
A: No.
Q: If I am under 18 years old can they tell my parents I went to a birth control clinic?
A: No matter how old you are, the clinics are not legally required to tell your parents that you had an appointment or received birth control. Most clinics are required by law to keep your visit confidential. If you are worried about your privacy, check with your clinic.
Q: What if I go to a hospital or private doctor for birth control or abortion? Will they notify my parents?
A: Hospitals and doctors are not required by law to tell your parents either. Most are required to respect your desire for confidentiality. Again, if you have any questions, check with them to make sure about your privacy.
Q: Is there a squeal rule?
A: No. The Squeal Rule was a regulation which would have made family planning clinics tell your parents if you got prescription birth control, like the pill or diaphragm. The Squeal Rule was stopped in court in 1983. It was never enforced.
Q: Can I get an abortion without my parents being told?
A: Yes. Clinics, doctors and hospitals are not required to tell your parents about your abortion. Most are required to protect your privacy. If you want confidentiality be sure to ask them about it.
Q: What about the bill? My parents would find out if a bill for abortion or birth control came to the house.
A: If you are not receiving free services, go to the billing department of your hospital, clinic, or doctor and tell them to send the bill to you in care of another address if you want to be sure your visits for birth control or abortion are confidential.
Q: Can a clinic make me tell my parents I am using birth control or having an abortion?
A: No. The clinic cannot make you talk to your parents. Under the law, the clinics are supposed to encourage teenagers who use birth control to talk with their parents about it. But nobody can force you to talk to them.
Q: Who can I call if I want to get information on confidential birth control and abortion services?
A: Call the Teen Pregnancy Networks in each of the five boroughs for this information.
